Snow Melting Nazi Image

Technique

Snow Melting Nazi

Snow melting on stoves: fuel efficiency, BTU trap explained, and tiered recommendations for summit, mountain, and basecamp use. Essential reading for winter expeditions and alpine climbing.

By Andy Kirkpatrick

November 4, 2021

Reading Time:12 minutes.

Good evening Mr Kirkpatrick,

I have a question regarding the optimal size (volume) for a cooking pot for melting snow on a multiday alpine-style climb which includes bivis in a tent or in the open.

I always thought the more volume the pot has, the less time and fuel you have to use to melt enough snow for drinking and cooking instant food. I also thought that this would outweigh the weight penalty of the bigger pot because the more often you have to melt pots full of snow, the less time you have to rest or sleep.

Or is melting snow in smaller pots so much faster?

I was a bit surprised because I have seen that many three-man rope teams in the high mountains only carry an MSR Reactor with a 1.7l pot (like Tom Livingstone and his partners did during their Latok ascent).

Btw. I love the Down book, so much attention to detail!

Best regards

Vincent K


Hi Vincent,

Thanks for your question. Rather than give you a tight and formal answer, here’s a bit of a brain splurge on stoves!

Pasta Nazis

Snow melting is a subject a little like cooking pasta. Some people just throw the pasta into cold water in a pan, crank up the heat, and cook it until it looks cooked. Others add the pasta to salted boiling water along with some olive oil, remove it while it’s al dente, season with a little more salt, add a tablespoon of olive oil, and serve. Which method is best? At the end of the day, both the imperfect and perfect approaches give you a plate of pasta; only one is perfect, the other less so (but only a pasta Nazi can tell the difference).

So it is with snow melting. You can be a snow-melting Nazi and treat it like pasta, or you can be a does-it-really-matter, slack Harry. Both work and will produce water — but when the chips are down (or the pasta), say you’ve only a thimbleful of fuel left or need to brew that life-saving cup of tea below the summit of Everest, being a Nazi might help.

Key Points

The key point of snow melting is both the volume of snow converted back into water per unit of fuel (fuel efficiency) and the speed of production (time efficiency).

For example:

If you’re sitting on a 100-gallon fuel drum at base camp, you can happily read to the end of your Dan Brown chapter while the water boils away. Neither fuel nor time efficiency matters, and stressing over a 60-second difference in boil time or 5 milligrams of white gas versus 5 milligrams of kerosene is just another form of wastage.

But if you’re perched on a ledge in your sleeping bag in a winter storm with just an egg cup of gas left in the canister, and every second spent cooking exposes you to the cold of the night, your life might depend on seconds and milligrams of fuel.

Somewhere between the two extremes is a three-person team at high camp, resting before their summit push, with rationed food and fuel but needing to hydrate maximally.

Added to these efficiencies are size, bulk, and weight — important if you only have a 30-litre pack, but less so with a pulk or jeep — plus safety concerns about the process (dangers of both gas and petrol stoves).

The BTU Trap

Very often people get sucked into the BTU (British thermal unit) trap, judging a stove solely by its BTU rating: an MSR Reactor (9,000 BTU) must be better than a Jetboil Zip (4,500 BTU), and both are trumped by an MSR WhisperLite (9,500 BTU).

You’ll find hundreds of YouTube videos of people in their kitchens boiling a litre of water to “prove” one stove is faster than another. This is a mistake.

Just as a Ford Mustang might seem better than a Ford Mondeo when the goal is simply getting from A to B five days a week for the life of the car, why choose a vehicle that quadruples your risk of dying even if it shaves a few minutes off the journey? It’s easy to build a very fast car, but what you gain in speed you may lose far more (in the Mustang’s case, possibly your life).

Put another way, a Falcon space rocket produces 109,941,300,000 BTUs, but it can’t sustain that output for long and is useless at making a nice cup of tea. A humble Trangia, on the other hand, putting out a pedestrian 3,500 BTU, will do so pretty much forever (as long as you top it up with spirit every half hour).

So it’s best to view BTUs the way you view a car’s top speed: work out whether your journey is Formula 1 or a drive from London to Cape Town. For most of us, it’s the latter.

Tiered Stoves

Before I go on, I’m going to break stoves into three tiers to help you better understand how to get what you want:

  • Tier 1: Summit stoves
  • Tier 2: ABC mountain stoves
  • Tier 3: Static camping or base-camp stoves
Foker Single Burner
Foker Single Burner

Tier 3 Stoves (Base-Camp Stove)

I’ve lived in several places that had either single, double, or quad gas rings hooked up to a large gas bottle (4 kg to 50 kg propane). This could be a stand-alone iron burner that was virtually indestructible or a tabletop kitchen burner — essentially a cooker top minus the oven.

This kind of stove is pretty much the standard kitchen set-up for the majority of people on the planet (at least those who have moved on from wood or dung fires).

In terms of utility and function, it cannot be beaten. You turn the rings on with a match and easily adjust the flame from boil to simmer, and the gas lasts for months or years (they also work during power cuts). If you’re a car camper, this — not a Jetboil or MSR — is what you really want.

Such a stove lets you vary the BTUs like any kitchen stove, from around 400 for simmering to 18,000 (or even higher for specialist models at 25,000 BTU).

The burners on these stoves — not camping stoves — are designed to handle medium, large, and extra-large pans, with much broader flame patterns (they don’t work well with your little titanium camping mug). This makes it far easier to cook large meals for many people than juggling big pans on small camping stoves.

You can also boil water on one ring while running a large wok or frying pan on another. These stoves are dirt cheap because the customer base is skint (that’s why an Aga costs as much as a car), so running multiple burners is perfectly affordable — you can buy a single cast-iron burner unit for around $50 or even less.

Although this style of stove isn’t going to be carried in a pack, it is the ideal heavy-duty base-camp stove. Its multi-burner design is perfect for melting snow in large pans (10 litres plus) and for maintaining a rolling boil or simmer (though you’ll usually transfer the water into large flasks).

So if you’re running a base-camp kitchen, cooking and melting snow for dozens of people, this is the stove you’ll use — not a dozen Jetboils. You won’t have to think hard about speed or fuel efficiency as long as you’re sensible.

MSR WhisperLite
MSR WhisperLite

Tier 2 Stoves (ABC Stove)

You can see the great advantages of a Tier 3 set-up, but that’s not the kind of trip you’re going on. You’re not going to take such a system on a plane (you’ll buy or rent it in-country) or carry it on your back; instead you’ll get dropped off with it (or carry it in a vehicle).

You’ll still be camping and out in the wild for an extended period — not survival/alpine-style cooking — but you need a portable option. And yet you still want some Tier 3 functionality: the ability to carry a multi-week or multi-month fuel supply, cook with both small and large pans, prepare complex or simple meals, and melt snow.

When working through your options, always nail redundancy first. A broken Jetboil might force a sad retreat down a climb, but a broken stove — when it’s the only one you have — on a remote glacier far from rescue is far more serious (you could end up burning your ropes to melt snow and survive until pickup).

This means you need a two-stove system at a minimum for a two-person team, or one stove per two people (a two- or four-person team carries two stoves; a six-person team carries three). Don’t forget that having two stoves doesn’t mean you can be careless with them. You still need a repair/spares kit, at least one spare pump, and multiple fuel bottles. (Stand on your only fuel bottle with your crampons and you’re done.)

Next is fuel. You don’t want to use gas cartridges for a Tier 2 stove because of bulk, cost, and sturdiness; liquid fuel (white gas or petrol) is your only sensible option.

With all liquid-fuel stoves you need a 100 % leak-proof and robust method of carrying fuel, especially if the containers will be physically or environmentally abused (plastic becomes brittle in the cold and can shatter). Remember that most fuel containers are designed to sit on a shelf, not inside a pack or pulk.

As a side note, the British lost around 25 % of their fuel during the North African desert campaigns of WWII because of poor-quality tin containers that were poorly designed and single-use. The problem was only partially solved by adopting captured multi-use German “jerrycans”.

Personally, I think it’s best to bite the bullet and carry all fuel in MSR fuel bottles (I own about 27 of them). This pretty much guarantees fuel security and removes the hassle of filling bottles. If you do fill bottles, take a funnel — ideally one with a filter — to keep rust and cockroaches out (and never store fuel anywhere near your food).

If MSR bottles aren’t an option, small or large car-style fuel containers work (orange plastic 5-litre ones or 20-litre metal jerrycans), but note that the more fuel you carry in a single container, the more you stand to lose if something happens to it (theft, spill, contamination, etc.).

The current expedition default is generally the MSR WhisperLite or XGK II stove, but my personal choice is the WhisperLite. It’s much quieter and has the ability to simmer (I’d add a simmer ring too). Some people swear by the XGK as the better expedition stove, but I used my WhisperLite (until it was stolen) pretty much every day for two years, from –50 °C to +50 °C, sea level to 17,000 feet, and it never let me down. (At super-cold temperatures you need to sleep with the fuel pumps to prevent leaking — a problem that also affects the XGK.)

Such a two-stove system can create a great base-camp kitchen when paired with a wooden cooking board, and both stoves can be used together under a large pan when speed is critical (useful for larger teams).

When weight becomes a factor you can take just one stove and gain the advantage of not having to worry about cold-induced pressure loss. The stove is also much improved in pan stability and fuel efficiency — and above all in CO avoidance — if you build a windshield/pan support (think Trangia set-up).

As for pan size, all such stoves are limited by flame diameter. A very large pan (10 litres) will only really work with two stoves (make sure the set-up is stable), so I wouldn’t go larger than a 2.5-litre or 20 cm pan; beyond that you start to lose efficiency.

One last point is fuel consumption. There’s a lot of conflicting advice. How much you need to carry depends on many factors: altitude, temperature (tap water, stream, or snow/ice), and the type of food (fresh or dried, pasta or brown rice). You also need to decide whether your consumption will be casual or calculated. It’s easy to spend a rest day brewing endless cups of tea and fried-egg sandwiches and burn a litre of gas on a route where a tenth of that would have sufficed.

As a baseline, for calculated summer use allow 120 ml of white gas per person; for winter/expedition use allow 200 ml. If consumption is casual, it doesn’t matter — you’ll probably be near a gas station anyway. The 200 ml figure can be reduced by perhaps 30 % with a high-quality windshield, heat exchanger, reflective stove board, and a single-boil strategy (you run the stove once a day and use flasks for breakfast drinks).

For snow melting, a 10-litre pan filled with snow may be easier and less time-consuming to monitor (just keep adding snow and let it melt), but in terms of fuel and time efficiency a carefully monitored 2.5-litre pan is better. This is doubly true if you also need to boil the water: it’s far faster to do the job four times with a 2.5-litre pan than once with a 10-litre pan, because large volumes on medium-BTU stoves often reach an equilibrium where the water cools faster than it can be heated (a second stove will shift that point).

On the subject of melting snow, one of the most important points is that your snow-melting/water-boiling pan should never be used for cooking. Doing so introduces food particles that contaminate the water and make it taste foul. This is most common when someone fills a pan to the top with snow and sticks it on a high flame. The snow touching the base melts and partly evaporates, leaving bare metal that superheats and burns any food particles, rendering the water undrinkable. Contaminants also include coffee, tea, or sports drinks. Keep your cooking pan(s) completely separate from your water pan.

MSR Reactor
MSR Reactor

Tier 1 Stoves (Summit Stoves)

This will generally be a single stove (unless you’re worried about having to bivvy separately; the weight of the burner on a Jetboil-style stove is minimal if each climber uses the pan as their personal mug/pan). It can be canister or liquid fuel, depending on the length of the trip and the consequences of stove failure (canister stoves have a higher failure rate, and most faults cannot be fixed in the field).

Here it’s important to focus on a one-pan system and keep that pan (you will generally have only one) exclusively for water. Use the water to rehydrate dehydrated food bags (an empty, clean dehydrated-food bag makes an excellent lightweight bowl).

A great story that illustrates this point is Colin Haley’s solo of Mount Hunter. Very thirsty and dehydrated with little gas left, he stuffed his Jetboil with snow, cranked it up, and waited for it to boil. Unbeknownst to him, remnants of his last meal in the pan had turned to carbon, creating a foul-tasting, undrinkable slush. He was left with no gas, no water, and a mouth full of foul poison. (This is the typical reality of doing a Bear Grylls and drinking your own piss.)

Tier 1 Strategy

Your question here is really about using a Tier 1 stove in a Tier 1 scenario.

On most climbs, when you’re using a Tier 1 stove you will have only a small pan (depending on team size) and limited fuel, so it’s best to do the following:

  1. When melting snow, get set up so everything is exactly where you need it. This limits the chances of spilling your hard-earned water. In camp this means having a bag for snow (an Ikea carrier bag works) or a stuff sack (good for high camp), plus something clean to scoop snow with — a mug or jug works best. Many plastic cups and jugs shatter in the cold, so a Lexan-style cup or mug is ideal. Avoid simply scooping snow from around camp; it can easily be contaminated by all sorts of nastiness as people move around. On one climb I did, someone even found a toenail in their dinner.
  2. Always begin snow melting by priming the pan with a little water. This can come from the remains of your day’s water ration (not if you’re using a sports drink). An alternative system (which won’t work for alpine-style climbing but works well on polar-style trips) is to use a flask and always leave a little water in the bottom to start the next melt. Priming prevents the pan from superheating and burning, and it generally makes the job faster.
  3. If you’re using priming water (or snow), start with a few centimetres of cold water, heat it to the beginning of a boil, then keep adding snow. The snow will instantly turn to water and cool the hot water as it does so.
  4. When you’re trying to fill your Nalgene bottles, melt about 120 % of the water you need. If you want it as a hot-water bottle for the night, bring it to the boil; if you want to save fuel, stop at hot. Transfer it to the bottle, leaving behind about 20 % as the primer for the next batch. This is much faster than melting and heating a full 2 litres, emptying the pan, and starting again.
  5. If you’re adding boiling water to food bags, cook 120 % of what you need, add the water, then melt more water while the food is rehydrating (place the bag inside your clothing for extra heat and invest in a large plastic WeLoc bag clip to avoid spills).
  6. It’s always faster to melt ice than snow, so if you’re finishing your stove duty, try to end with a little ice in the pan. It will speed things up in the morning if you don’t have priming water.

Wilderness Factors

The most fuel-efficient approach in a wilderness setting must be weighed against a number of factors — some environmental, others practical, and sometimes even cost-related. These include altitude, temperature, weight/bulk allowance, access to fuel, and safety (both CO and fire).

A good-quality gas stove with a brand-new canister, at sea level on a summer’s day, will rapidly turn a bag of ice cubes into several cups of tea. Anyone testing such a stove before a trip to climb the Cassin Ridge will no doubt feel confident in their ability to produce life-giving liquid for the team, both to hydrate bodies and rehydrate food.

Now move to 14,000 feet with a half-full gas canister (your last one), temperatures below –20 °C, a broken integral sparker, and all your lighters wet. You may struggle to produce even cold water. If you’re lucky you’ll be experienced enough to cook during the warmer part of the day, you’ll have a flint and steel, and you’ll be using a highly efficient Reactor or Jetboil with a heat exchanger to counteract the cold (or simply warming the canister with your hands).

An alternative summer sea-level test would be running an MSR WhisperLite with a full bottle of white gas. As above, you’d rapidly turn those ice cubes into tea. That set-up would lose points, however, for being a bit heavier and bulkier, more expensive (because it deals with raw fuel that must be preheated), dirtier, and not a foolproof push-and-go option — it requires priming and a certain level of skill to use safely and effectively.

But transport that same stove to 14,000 feet with half a bottle of fuel and extreme cold, and how does it perform? Exactly the same as it did in your kitchen.

The difference — perhaps while perched on a tiny ledge — is which stove has the greatest utility, irrespective of efficiency, speed, or fuel consumption. I know people who have used a Jetboil inside their sleeping bag; you can’t do that with an XGK.

Sure, the liquid-fuel stove might produce a pan of boiling water, but priming it while it’s balanced on your knees and then balancing the pan on top requires far more skill than simply firing up a Reactor.

A Note on Cold, Hot, and Boiling Water

A unit of gas or petrol will produce ten times more cold water than boiling water, and about five times as much hot water. This is an important point in a survival or fuel-rationing scenario, because cold water has just as much hydrating value as boiling water. Boiling is only essential when you need to rehydrate dry food (though even then, in an emergency you can soak dried food overnight in cold water). You can also stuff the bag with snow and keep it inside your clothing while moving or inside your sleeping bag.

Forgoing hot drinks can be tough on team morale, but if it’s only for a night or two, it’s far better than the alternative — deep and debilitating thirst (made all the worse by being surrounded by water).

{title} image
PV Podcast

Read More

Writing

New Kickstarter Project: The Beyond

By Andy Kirkpatrick

Reflections

Midnight Run

A midnight emergency run across Lough Corrib with a badly burned child—fear, mistakes, and instinct collide in this raw story of risk, parenting, and consequence.

By Andy Kirkpatrick

Reflections

G is for Garibotti

A quiet evening in Rolando Garibotti’s Boulder kitchen in 2004 reveals the human side of one of Patagonia’s greatest climbers. A personal reflection on talent, illness, humility, and the day climbing regained its wonder.

By Andy Kirkpatrick

Reflections

U is for Unknown Pleasures

What do you really get out of climbing? Not just the views. A deeply personal reflection on the small, unexpected rewards of mountaineering — from frost-nipped fingers and cheap tea to coming home changed.

By Andy Kirkpatrick

Climbing

GriGri Unconfidential

A raw, honest confession about repeatedly fucking up with the Petzl GriGri — misthreading, open-device rappels, and the psychology of climber errors. Not a gear review, but a deep look at why we all make mistakes and why honesty matters more than looking competent.

By Andy Kirkpatrick

Climbing

Beyond Help

When professional rescue isn’t coming: A gripping account of a near-fatal fall in Kenya and a fatal accident in Kalymnos. Essential reading on self-rescue, expectations vs reality, and staying alive in the mountains.

By Andy Kirkpatrick

Climbing

Psycho Vertical (2017)

"Psycho Vertical: a raw climbing film about fear, obsession, and pushing into the vertical unknown, where control slips and consequences bite."

By Andy Kirkpatrick

Reflections

Brotherhood of Rope

Andy Kirkpatrick returns to climbing after a neglected bicep injury, grappling with ego-bruising restarts, chaotic family crag days, and the raw futility of the sport. Reflections on old friends, near-misses, and the heavy shadow of suicide—including the sudden loss of a charismatic climbing mate and a salvific message from a fallen hero—explore pain, connection, and why words can feel like morphine when life unravels. Intimate, humorous, and unflinching.

By Andy Kirkpatrick